2026年09月03日 星期四

Meta AI Bot在被下线前曾大量错误引用科学家的话

这就像一个花哨的游戏版本,你开始写半句话,然后让自动完成填充剩下的故事。”

上周,Meta暂停了它的人工智能(AI)机器人,就在它向公众发布仅两天后。这个名为卡拉狄加的机器人接受了“1060亿个开放获取的科学文本和数据令牌”的训练。这包括论文、教科书、科学网站、百科全书、参考资料、知识库等等,”该公司告诉 The Daily Beast

它本应帮助学者和研究人员快速简洁地找到论文和研究,但取而代之的是被大量错误引用著名科学家的信息所淹没。如果文章中错误地引用了科学家的话,他们的声誉可能会受到威胁。华盛顿大学生物学教授卡尔·伯格斯特罗姆告诉CNET,卡拉狄加的问题在于,它被宣传为获取事实和信息的一种方式。但相反,他说,这就像“一个花哨的游戏版本,你开始写半句话,然后让自动完成填充剩下的故事。”

在卡拉狄加上线后的几个小时内,用户开始报告种族主义和不准确的文章,其中一人发布了一张回应语言偏见请求的图片。该机器人的回应错误地声称黑人“没有自己的语言”,移民“不会说一种与他们移民国家的语言不同的语言”。

其他产生的信息包括一项关于吃碎玻璃的好处的虚假研究,以及斯坦福大学研究人员开发一种“同性恋雷达”软件来在Facebook上寻找同性恋者的虚假信息。

一位Meta AI的发言人告诉CNET,“卡拉狄加不是真相的来源,它是一个使用(机器学习)系统来学习和总结信息的研究实验。”他补充说,卡拉狄加“是短期的探索性研究,没有产品计划。”Meta AI首席科学家Yann LeCun告诉媒体,该机器人被移除是因为团队“被推特上的刻薄言论弄得心烦意乱”。

卡拉狄加发布两天后,Meta AI团队暂停了机器人,Meta的首席AI科学家Yann LeCun在推特上说:“卡拉狄加的演示现在离线了。通过随意滥用它来获得乐趣已经不可能了。开心呢?”

Meta AI(之前被称为Facebook人工智能研究)开发了卡拉狄加,作为一种“组织科学”的方式,并浓缩了网上发现的大量科学信息。他们的想法是让人工智能做一些事情,比如解决数学问题、编写科学代码和编写研究摘要。

Meta在卡拉狄加网站上指出,AI模型确实有可能导致“幻觉”的局限性。该网站建议用户验证弹出的任何信息,并继续说“语言模型的输出不能保证真实或可靠,即使是在卡拉狄加这样的高质量数据上的大型输出,”并补充说,生成的文本可能看起来“非常真实和高度自信”,但它仍然可能是错误的。

匹兹堡卡耐基梅隆大学计算机科学教授文森特·科尼策在接受《每日野兽》采访时表示:“我认为,即使这样的系统有许多可预见的缺陷,它也有可取的用途。”

“我的印象是,如果Meta在这次公开发布中投入更多的精力,首先进行更认真的用户研究,让人们注意到系统的可取用途,并诚实和坦率地对待不可取的用途,本可以做得更好。”

原文:

Meta paused its Artificial Intelligence (AI) bot last week, only two days after it went live to the public. The bot, called Galactica, was trained “on 106 billion tokens of open-access scientific text and data. This includes papers, textbooks, scientific websites, encyclopedias, reference material, knowledge bases, and more,” the company told The Daily Beast.

It was supposed to help academics and researchers find papers and studies quickly and succinctly but instead was overwhelmed by vast amounts of misinformation that incorrectly cited reputable scientists.

Related Stories
The Vision Vanish Is the First Laser Projector With Its Own Disappearing Screen
Watch NowHow to Use Apple’s Spatial Audio on AirPods Max and Pro
Acer’s Bike Desk Harnesses Your Anxious Work Energy To Charge Your Devices
Scientists’ reputations could be put on the line when they’re incorrectly cited in the text and Carl Bergstrom, a professor of biology at the University of Washington told CNET that Galactica’s problem is it was promoted as a way to get facts and information. But instead, he said it acted like “a fancy version of the game where you start out with a half sentence, then you let autocomplete fill in the rest of the story.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Within hours of Galactica going live, users started reporting racist and inaccurate articles, with one person posting an image of the response to a request about linguistic prejudice. The bot’s response falsely claimed Black people “don’t have a language of their own” and immigrants “do not speak a language that is different from the language of the country they are immigrating to.”

Other generated information included a fake study about the benefits of eating crushed glass and falsified information about Stanford University researchers creating a “gaydar” software to find gay people on Facebook.

A Meta AI spokesperson told CNET, “Galactica is not a source of truth, it is a research experiment using [machine learning] systems to learn and summarize information.” He added, Galactica “is exploratory research that is short-term in nature with no product plans.” Meta AI Chief Scientist Yann LeCun told the outlet the bot was removed because the team was “so distraught by the vitriol on Twitter.”

Two days after Galactica’s launch, the Meta AI team paused the bot and Meta’s chief AI scientist Yann LeCun tweeted, “Galactica demo is offline for now. It’s no longer possible to have some fun by casually misusing it. Happy?”

ADVERTISEMENT
Meta AI (previously called Facebook Artificial Intelligence Research) developed Galactica as a way to “organize science” and condense an overwhelming amount of scientific information found online. The idea was to have the AI do things like solve math problems, write scientific code, and craft summaries of research.

Meta does note on the Galactica website that the AI model does have limitations that can cause it to “hallucinate.” The site advises users to verify any information that pops up and goes on to say “There are no guarantees for truthful or reliable output from language models, even large ones on high-quality data like Galactica,” adding that the generated text might appear “very authentic and highly confident,” but it could still be wrong.

ADVERTISEMENT
“I imagine that even with its many predictable flaws, there are desirable uses of such a system,” Vincent Conitzer, a professor of computer science at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh, told The Daily Beast.

“My impression is that Meta would have done better by putting more effort into this public release, by doing more serious user studies first, drawing attention to desirable uses of the system, and being honest and forthcoming about undesirable uses.”

本文由数字化转型网(www.szhzxw.cn)翻译而成,作者:Nikki Main;编辑/翻译:数字化转型网默然。

扫码加入数字化转型网读者交流社群

免责声明: 本网站(https://www.szhzxw.cn/)内容主要来自原创、合作媒体供稿和第三方投稿,凡在本网站出现的信息,均仅供参考。本网站将尽力确保所提供信息的准确性及可靠性,但不保证有关资料的准确性及可靠性,读者在使用前请进一步核实,并对任何自主决定的行为负责。本网站对有关资料所引致的错误、不确或遗漏,概不负任何法律责任。
本网站刊载的所有内容(包括但不仅限文字、图片、LOGO、音频、视频、软件、程序等) 版权归原作者所有。任何单位或个人认为本网站中的内容可能涉嫌侵犯其知识产权或存在不实内容时,请及时通知本站,予以删除。

CXOU AI 未来大会 · 报名通道限时开启
💬 评论
🔗 本文链接

📰 你可能也喜欢

人工智能案例集|丰田 Toyota:AI驱动的自动驾驶与智能制造双引擎转型——数智化转型网www.szhzxw.cn 专题栏目

人工智能案例集|丰田 Toyota:AI驱动的自动驾驶与智能制造双引擎转型

丰田(Toyota Motor Corporation)作为全球年销量近千万辆的汽车制造商,正以” […]
📅 08-31 · 👁 2026年8月31日
GEO专题

品牌在AI搜索中的可见性:影响因素与评估维度

一、什么是品牌AI搜索可见性 品牌在AI搜索中的可见性(AI Search Visibility)指的是品牌在 […]
📅 08-26 · 👁 2026年8月26日
GEO专题

2026年AI搜索现状:零点击时代已经到来

一、零点击搜索的定义与现状 零点击搜索(Zero-Click Search)指的是用户通过搜索引擎或AI工具获 […]
📅 08-26 · 👁 2026年8月26日
GEO专题

五大GEO策略:让AI搜索主动推荐你的品牌

想让AI在生成答案时主动推荐你的品牌,需要掌握科学的GEO策略。根据ClickForest、Search En […]
📅 08-26 · 👁 2026年8月26日
GEO专题

GEO与SEO的本质区别:从排名到信任的跨越

一、SEO的时代正在远去? 过去二十年,SEO(搜索引擎优化)一直是企业数字营销的核心。通过优化关键词、外链建 […]
📅 08-26 · 👁 2026年8月26日
人工智能案例|索尼:PlayStation AI 助手 + Intelligent Vision Sensor 的非纯 AI 传统巨头 AI 化样本——数智化转型网www.szhzxw.cn 专题栏目

人工智能案例|索尼:PlayStation AI 助手 + Intelligent Vision Sensor 的非纯 AI 传统巨头 AI 化样本

作为全球影音娱乐、游戏、半导体、影像四大业务的科技巨头,索尼(Sony Group Corporation, […]
📅 08-26 · 👁 2026年8月26日