“人工智能+教育”将面临哪些挑战？
在全球范围内，人工智能技术的持续发展已然成为推动教育变革的重要力量。人工智能技术与教育的深度融合不仅对教学方式和学习方式产生了深远的影响，更触及了教育理念的核心，必将推动教育范式的根本性变革。然而，犹如一把双刃剑，人工智能技术在教育领域的广泛应用，也给教育发展与变革带来了一系列问题与挑战。 数字化转型网www.szhzxw.cn
● 技术层面的挑战。
技术适用性挑战。当前的人工智能技术，尽管已取得了显著的进步，但在面对教育的复杂场景时，仍显得力不从心。人工智能的本质在于模拟人类的智能，它依赖算法与数据来执行任务，为教育提供了个性化学习与教学的新方式，提升了教育的效率与体验。然而，这项技术尚未达到完全成熟的阶段，仍面临学习数据稀疏性所带来的挑战，这可能导致个性化方案精准性有所欠缺，同时，在数据资源有限的情况下，模型亦存在以偏概全的现象。这些问题不仅影响了人工智能在教育中的深度应用，也导致市场上的许多教育人工智能产品在实际应用中显得不够“智能”，难以满足教育场景中多变且复杂的需求。
技术依赖风险。人工智能技术在教育领域的广泛应用，也带来一个潜在的风险，即教育者和管理者可能会过度依赖这些技术来解决教学和管理上的问题，学习者也可能过度依赖人工智能技术获取知识和信息，这种依赖可能导致教与学的“技术依赖症”，而忽视教学过程中的反思和学习过程中的独立思考重要性。因此，尽管人工智能在教育领域的应用呈现出不可逆转的趋势，我们仍应当坚守教育初心，持续聚焦于教育的核心价值和人的全面发展，避免技术过度主导而削弱教育的育人功能。
● 数据安全与隐私保护的挑战。
斯坦福大学发布的《2024年人工智能指数报告》指出，技术的不断进步和广泛运用显著提升生产力，但目前的人工智能技术的推广和应用也可能受限于技术自身的局限性，并引发隐私、错误信息传播及知识产权风险等问题。
数据安全的挑战。在数据的收集、存储和传输过程中，确保数据的安全性至关重要。在教育领域中，所累积的数据不仅涵盖了学生的基础个人信息，更涉及他们学习过程中的重要记录，如学习进度、学业成绩以及行为模式等敏感数据。这类信息具有高度的隐私性和敏感性，若不慎泄露或被恶意利用，将对学生个体的安全构成严重威胁，并可能对整体教育系统的稳定与健康运行产生不良影响。因此，如何建立起一套完善的数据安全机制，以确保数据在整个生命周期内的安全，在人工智能技术应用领域已成为亟待解决且至关重要的任务。 数字化转型网www.szhzxw.cn
隐私保护的挑战。在“人工智能+教育”场景下，大量的学生数据被收集和分析，以便为每个学生提供个性化的学习方案。学生的个人信息、学习行为和成绩等都属于个人隐私范畴，这些数据的收集和使用必须建立在充分尊重学生隐私的基础上。然而，在实践中，由于理念、技术和管理等多方面因素的影响，学生隐私的保护可能会面临不确定性。在“人工智能+教育”的融合发展中，学生隐私的保护问题同样需要被给予高度关注，以确保教育环境的安全与可靠。
● 价值层面的挑战。
在教育领域，价值观和伦理道德观是不可或缺的一部分，如何确保人工智能技术在教育领域的应用符合社会的期望和要求，是“人工智能+教育”在价值层面需要直面的挑战。
技术产品的价值功能缺位。当前，多数人工智能教育产品主要集中在自适应学习领域，它们通过智能算法为学生提供定制化的学习内容和反馈。然而，教育的目标远不止知识的传授，还包括学生的全面发展，如社交技能、心理素质、道德品质等方面的培养。而现有的人工智能教育产品在这些素质方面的培养则显得不足，人工智能教育产品在价值层面的功能缺陷在一定程度上限制了人工智能技术在教育领域的全面应用和深远影响。 数字化转型网www.szhzxw.cn
不同价值观的协调难题。在全球化和信息化日益深入发展的时代背景下，社会思想观念日益呈现出多样化的特征。推动“人工智能+教育”的融合进程中，确保人工智能技术的运用能够顺应这种多样化的发展趋势，特别是与社会的核心价值观和伦理道德观相契合，已成为一项亟待解决且充满挑战的任务。具体而言，不同场景下对文化的理解和实践存在显著差异。例如，在某些企业，集体主义和团队精神被视为重要的价值导向；而在另外一些企业，个人奋斗则可能受到推崇。因此，人工智能技术产品的设计与应用应该充分考虑这些文化差异，以避免造成误导。 数字化转型网www.szhzxw.cn
● 知识生产与传播方式方面的挑战。
人工智能技术应用的不断深入，不仅改变了知识的生产和传播方式，还对人才培养模式提出了全新的挑战。知识生产方式变革对学生独立思考的挑战。人工智能技术进步改变了人类获取、创造和应用知识的方式。知识生产方式的自动化和智能化降低了知识获取的门槛，但过度依赖人工智能生成的内容可能会形成学生在学习上的惰性，导致学生逐渐丧失自主寻找、筛选和整合信息的能力。这种变革对学生独立思考能力带来了新的挑战。
知识传播方式上的范式革命对学校功能的挑战。人工智能技术的应用对知识传播方式带来了显著的改变。传统的“师-生”二元教学模式正逐渐转变为“师-机-生”的三元结构。在这个新模式下，教师、机器和学生三者之间相互促进、相互影响，共同推动智能化教育的发展。然而，这种转变也意味着人们对学校的观念将应时而变，即学校知识传授功能将会被弱化，这也对学校在知识传播上的功能定位提出了挑战。
● 教师和学生角色适应的挑战。
“人工智能+教育”场景下，教师和学生的角色发生变化，都需要不断地学习以更好地适应教育场景的变革。教师角色适应的挑战。在“人工智能+教育”场景下，教师不再仅仅是知识的传授者，而是要逐渐演变为学生学习过程中的引导者和辅助者。这不仅要求教师具备扎实的专业知识，还要求他们掌握一系列新的教学工具和方法，这种转变无疑对教师提出了更高的要求。学生角色适应的挑战。在“人工智能+教育”场景下，学生不仅要具备良好的自主学习能力，还要具备与人工智能技术进行有效互动的能力。这对在传统学习模式下处于被动接受者的部分学生而言，自主学习将面临前所未有的挑战和困境，可能会进一步拉大学业成绩差距。
● 资源共享方面的挑战。
尽管人工智能技术为教育带来了很多机遇，但也对公平性提出了挑战。如何让所有学生都能享受到人工智能技术应用带来的好处，成为一项至关重要的议题。
“算法黑箱”引发的透明度担忧。“算法黑箱”指的是算法的内部逻辑和决策过程对用户来说是不透明和难以理解的，因此很难检测和纠正其中的错误，基于这些错误而做出的决策，则可能对公平性产生负面影响。“算法黑箱”通常通过算法偏见、透明性欠缺等问题凸显出来。技术势差影响应用成本。具体来说，部分发达地区和学校由于具备较为丰富的教育资源和财政经费支持，能够拥有相对较好的技术基础设施，这些地区和学校就能够更早、更全面地利用人工智能技术来辅助教学，进而为学生提供更为丰富、高效的学习体验。反之，偏远地区或经济条件较差的学校则可能无法承担高昂的技术成本，从而在人工智能教育资源配置方面面临不同的境遇。 数字化转型网www.szhzxw.cn
数字化转型网人工智能专题
与全球关注人工智能的顶尖精英一起学习！数字化转型网建立了一个专门讨论人工智能技术、产业、学术的研究学习社区，与各位研习社同学一起成长！欢迎扫码加入！ 数字化转型网www.szhzxw.cn
本文由数字化转型网（www.szhzxw.cn）转载而成，来源于网络；编辑/翻译：数字化转型网宁檬树。
翻译：
What challenges will “AI + Education” face?
On a global scale, the continuous development of artificial intelligence technology has become an important force to promote education change. The deep integration of artificial intelligence technology and education has not only had a profound impact on teaching methods and learning methods, but also touched the core of education concepts, and will certainly promote the fundamental change of education paradigm. However, like a double-edged sword, the wide application of artificial intelligence technology in the field of education has also brought a series of problems and challenges to the development and reform of education. 数字化转型网www.szhzxw.cn
● Technical challenges.
Technical applicability challenge. Current artificial intelligence technology, despite significant progress, is still inadequate in the face of complex scenarios in education. The essence of artificial intelligence is to simulate human intelligence, which relies on algorithms and data to perform tasks, provides a new way of personalized learning and teaching for education, and improves the efficiency and experience of education. However, this technology has not yet reached the stage of full maturity, and still faces the challenge brought by the sparsity of learning data, which may lead to the lack of accuracy of personalized schemes. At the same time, in the case of limited data resources, the model is also biased. These problems not only affect the deep application of artificial intelligence in education, but also cause many educational artificial intelligence products on the market to be not “intelligent” enough in practical application, and it is difficult to meet the changing and complex needs of the education scene.
Technology depends on risk. The wide application of artificial intelligence technology in the field of education also brings a potential risk, that is, educators and managers may over-rely on these technologies to solve teaching and management problems, and learners may over-rely on artificial intelligence technology to obtain knowledge and information, which may lead to “technology dependence syndrome” in teaching and learning. The importance of independent thinking in the process of teaching and learning is ignored. Therefore, although the application of artificial intelligence in the field of education shows an irreversible trend, we should still adhere to the original intention of education, continue to focus on the core value of education and the comprehensive development of people, and avoid the excessive dominance of technology and weaken the educational function of education.
● Data security and privacy protection challenges.
According to the 2024 Artificial Intelligence Index report released by Stanford University, continuous progress and widespread use of technology have significantly improved productivity, but the promotion and application of current artificial intelligence technologies may also be limited by the limitations of the technology itself, and raise issues such as privacy, the spread of misinformation and intellectual property risks. 数字化转型网www.szhzxw.cn
Data security challenges. During the collection, storage and transmission of data, it is important to ensure the security of data. In the field of education, the accumulated data not only covers the basic personal information of students, but also involves important records in their learning process, such as sensitive data such as learning progress, academic performance and behavior patterns. This kind of information has a high degree of privacy and sensitivity, if inadvertently leaked or maliciously used, will pose a serious threat to the safety of individual students, and may have an adverse impact on the stability and healthy operation of the overall education system. Therefore, how to establish a set of perfect data security mechanism to ensure the safety of data in the whole life cycle has become an urgent and crucial task in the field of artificial intelligence technology application.
The challenge of privacy protection. In the “AI + Education” scenario, large amounts of student data are collected and analyzed in order to provide a personalized learning program for each student. Students’ personal information, learning behavior and grades are all in the category of personal privacy, and the collection and use of such data must be based on full respect for students’ privacy. However, in practice, due to the influence of many factors such as philosophy, technology and management, the protection of student privacy may face uncertainties. In the integrated development of “artificial intelligence + education”, the protection of students’ privacy also needs to be given high attention to ensure the safety and reliability of the educational environment.
● Value challenges.
In the field of education, values and ethics are an indispensable part, and how to ensure that the application of artificial intelligence technology in the field of education meets the expectations and requirements of society is a challenge that “artificial intelligence + education” needs to face in terms of value. 数字化转型网www.szhzxw.cn
The value function of technical products is absent. At present, most AI education products are mainly focused on adaptive learning, which provides students with customized learning content and feedback through intelligent algorithms. However, the goal of education is far more than the transfer of knowledge, but also includes the overall development of students, such as the cultivation of social skills, psychological quality, moral character and so on. However, the existing artificial intelligence education products are insufficient in the cultivation of these qualities, and the functional defects of artificial intelligence education products in the value level limit the comprehensive application and far-reaching impact of artificial intelligence technology in the field of education to a certain extent.
The difficulty of reconciling different values. Under the background of the deepening development of globalization and information technology, social ideas and concepts are increasingly diversified. In the process of promoting the integration of “artificial intelligence + education”, ensuring that the application of artificial intelligence technology can comply with this diversified development trend, especially with the core values and ethics of society, has become an urgent and challenging task. Specifically, there are significant differences in the understanding and practice of culture in different scenarios. For example, in some enterprises, collectivism and team spirit are regarded as important value orientation; In other companies, personal endeavor may be celebrated. Therefore, the design and application of artificial intelligence technology products should fully consider these cultural differences to avoid misleading.
● Challenges in the way knowledge is produced and disseminated.
The continuous deepening of the application of artificial intelligence technology not only changes the production and dissemination of knowledge, but also poses a new challenge to the mode of talent training. The challenge of the transformation of knowledge production mode to students’ independent thinking. Advances in artificial intelligence have changed the way humans acquire, create, and apply knowledge. The automation and intelligence of knowledge production mode have lowered the threshold of knowledge acquisition, but over-reliance on the content generated by artificial intelligence may form students’ inertia in learning, resulting in students gradually losing the ability to independently search, screen and integrate information. This change has brought new challenges to students’ ability of independent thinking. 数字化转型网www.szhzxw.cn
The challenge of the paradigm revolution in the mode of knowledge dissemination to the function of schools. The application of artificial intelligence technology has brought about significant changes in the way knowledge is transmitted. The traditional “teacher-student” dual teaching mode is gradually changing into “teacher-machine-student” ternary structure. In this new model, teachers, machines and students promote and influence each other, and jointly promote the development of intelligent education. However, this change also means that people’s concept of school will change with The Times, that is, the function of school knowledge transmission will be weakened, which also challenges the functional positioning of school knowledge transmission.
● The challenge of adapting the roles of teachers and students.
In the “artificial intelligence + education” scenario, the roles of teachers and students have changed, and they need to constantly learn to better adapt to the changes in the education scene. The challenge of teacher role adaptation. In the “artificial intelligence + education” scenario, teachers are no longer just imparted knowledge, but gradually evolve into guides and assistants in the learning process of students. This not only requires teachers to have solid professional knowledge, but also requires them to master a range of new teaching tools and methods, and this shift undoubtedly puts higher demands on teachers. The challenge of student role adaptation. In the “artificial intelligence + education” scenario, students should not only have good autonomous learning ability, but also have the ability to effectively interact with artificial intelligence technology. For some students who are passive recipients under the traditional learning mode, independent learning will face unprecedented challenges and difficulties, which may further widen the academic achievement gap.
● Resource sharing challenges.
While AI technology presents many opportunities for education, it also poses challenges for equity. How to allow all students to enjoy the benefits of the application of artificial intelligence technology has become a crucial issue. 数字化转型网www.szhzxw.cn
Transparency concerns raised by “algorithmic black boxes”. Algorithmic black box refers to the fact that the internal logic and decision-making process of an algorithm is opaque and difficult for users to understand, so it is difficult to detect and correct errors in it, and decisions based on these errors may have a negative impact on fairness. “Algorithmic black boxes” are often highlighted by problems such as algorithmic bias and lack of transparency. Technology potential difference affects application cost. Specifically, some developed regions and schools, due to their rich educational resources and financial support, can have relatively good technical infrastructure, and these regions and schools can use artificial intelligence technology to assist teaching earlier and more comprehensively, thus providing students with a richer and more efficient learning experience. Conversely, schools in remote areas or with poor economic conditions may not be able to afford the high cost of technology, and thus face different situations in the allocation of artificial intelligence education resources.
